Post Publication Peer Review

At Nordic Open Science, we believe that scholarly publishing should be transparent, dynamic, and inclusive. Our Post-Publication Peer Review (PPPR) model enhances traditional peer review by allowing ongoing expert evaluation, open discussion, and community engagement after an article is published. This model not only strengthens research quality and integrity but also recognizes the invaluable contributions of reviewers and editors by making their names and evaluations publicly available alongside the articles they assess.

By shifting from a closed and static review system to an open and evolving process, we aim that research remains rigorous, verifiable, and continuously refined while fostering a culture of collaboration, recognition, and transparency. For more details on the peer review process, visit the How it Works page.

 

Key Features of Our Peer Review Process

• Open Identities & Recognition for Reviewers and Editors

  Unlike traditional anonymous peer review, our model openly acknowledges the contributions of reviewers and editors, giving them well-deserved credit for their expertise and effort. Reviewer names, review reports, and editorial decisions are published alongside the article, ensuring accountability and scholarly trust.

• Expert-Led Evaluation with Author Involvement

  Our Editorial Team carefully selects qualified reviewers based on subject expertise. Authors may also suggest potential reviewers, fostering a more collaborative and inclusive evaluation process.

• Interactive & Collaborative Discussions
  Authors, reviewers, and the broader academic community can actively engage in scholarly discussions, offering new perspectives and refining research findings in real-time. This dynamic exchange enhances interdisciplinary collaboration and strengthens scientific discourse.

• Evolving & Living Research
  Peer review does not end at publication—authors can revise and update their work based on feedback, ensuring that the research remains relevant, accurate, and impactful over time.

• Specialized Review for Complex Studies
  For research involving advanced statistical analyses, novel methodologies, or interdisciplinary approaches, additional expert evaluations are sought to ensure a thorough and high-quality review process.

• AI-Enhanced Workflow for Efficiency
  We integrate AI-powered tools to assist in reviewer selection, detect potential issues, and streamline the peer review process while maintaining human oversight to ensure quality and fairness.

By embracing an open and evolving peer review model, Nordic Open Science empowers researchers to engage in meaningful discussions, enhances research transparency, and drives scientific innovation.

 

Core Principles of PPPR

Our Post-Publication Peer Review model is built on four key principles:

• Transparency & Recognition
  Open peer review ensures that reviewers and editors receive public credit for their contributions. Their evaluations are openly published, fostering accountability, trust, and academic integrity.

• Community Engagement
  By allowing the broader research community to contribute feedback, we leverage diverse expertise and perspectives, promoting a collaborative approach to scientific validation.

• Continuous Improvement
  PPPR allows authors to refine their work based on ongoing feedback, ensuring that research is continuously updated to reflect new data, alternative interpretations, and corrections.

• Openness & Accessibility
  Our open peer review system ensures that all research and its evaluations are freely accessible, removing barriers to knowledge and fostering an inclusive scholarly environment.

 

How Our Post-Publication Peer Review Works

• Open Commentary & Expert Review
  After publication, articles remain open for feedback, expert review, and discussion from the global research community.

• Recognition & Transparency
  Reviewer names and detailed peer review reports are published alongside the article, ensuring proper acknowledgment and enhancing research credibility.

• Moderation & Quality Control
  All comments and reviews undergo moderation to ensure they are constructive, relevant, and adhere to ethical guidelines, maintaining a respectful and high-quality scholarly dialogue.

• Author Engagement & Response
  Authors are encouraged to engage with reviewers and respond to feedback, fostering an ongoing scholarly exchange that improves research quality.

• Revisions & Updates
  Based on expert feedback and community insights, authors may submit revisions or updates that are linked to the original publication, ensuring that readers always have access to the most current and comprehensive version of the research.

 

Why PPPR Matters: The Benefits

• Enhanced Research Rigor
  Open and continuous peer review strengthens the validity, credibility, and impact of published research.

• Recognition for Reviewers & Editors
  Unlike traditional peer review, our system formally acknowledges the efforts of reviewers and editors, providing academic recognition for their contributions.

• Broader Validation & Collaboration
  A wider range of experts and researchers contribute to the evaluation process, diversifying perspectives and strengthening interdisciplinary collaboration.

• Dynamic & Evolving Scholarship
  PPPR transforms research into a living document, reflecting the ever-changing landscape of scientific discovery while remaining open to refinement and improvement.

At Nordic Open Science, we invite researchers, academics, and practitioners to actively engage in our Post-Publication Peer Review process. Your contributions are essential in advancing scientific knowledge, ensuring research integrity, and fostering an open and collaborative academic environment.

Join our Editorial Board and help shape the future of open science through Post-Publication Peer Review at Nordic Open Science!

 

Welcome to Nordic Open Research.
Open Minds. Open Access. Open Research.